If one could crawl inside a psychologists office, one would soon realize that human beings are liars. They lie to themselves, they lie to the world and God. God in fact is used to numb, deny, obfuscate and cope with the most heinous injustice and crime behind a smiling and happy face.
When Jahir Jaffer’s family sit in court praying on Tasbihs…..it sends a shock wave through society who wonder, do we pray to the same God for justice for Noor? Who are we praying to? The same God that sat in heavan, watching a very rich and very psychopathic man rape, kill and then behead a friend he danced with a short year ago. A girl who looked at him lovingly, like friends who trust each other do. But, alas, God didn’t descend to save Noor when she tried to escape from her captor several times. In fact, the domestic servants ensured that she couldn’t run from the house. It doesn’t surprise anyone that they didn’t raise a finger to help her. It doesn’t surprise anyone that his parents who must have gathered from their dozens of calls that something was afoot, didn’t do anything to save Noor.
When Zakir Jaffer was arrested, he said, ‘we want justice to prevail’. I don’t think it was justice that he meant, he actually meant “Just Is.” Just Is is a state of blaming the victim that freezes any process of truth and justice. So what is Just Is?
Just Is
In a state where Just Is prevails, friendship couldn’t save the day. In a culture, where people generally stop what they are doing to help a stranger, nobody helped an injured bleeding girl escape when her friend became violent.
Just Is means that the entire family and friends and domestic servants were outside or on the phone while Zahir killed Noor. The murder was done on the celebratory holiday of Eid where the men take a knife, mouth a prayer then slice an animals neck as a symbol of sacrifice for God. This time in 2021, a girl was sacrificed. This too is Just Is.
In Pakistan’s history many fundamentalists have beheaded people. For example Daniel Pearl, a journalist was beheaded. The ISIS and Taliban have beheaded countless people to exert control and authority. Jahir Jaffer must be around 30 years old. He probably grew up inundated by the news of Islamic terrorism in the shape of bombs, shootings and beheadings. These killings were done ostensibly for God — but we all know that killing isn’t about God, it is about power and ego.
The killing was done for his male ego. Jahir stated that the murder was done because Noor refused to marry him. One wonders why he would want to marry a woman he hated so much that he killed her. But here is the reality of Pakistan. There is not much love between people who have sex. In fact the fastest way to kill any love between a man and a woman is to get them married. There is domination, power and control towards women. In other words, men don’t respect women they have sex with, they own them.
There is A LOT of victim blaming. Why did she go to his house? why did she call him so many times? why was she dating him? shouldn’t she have done a nikah? As if a nikah would mean that he wouldn’t kill her.
If you scan the headlines of the last 6 months, there is a repeated theme of women, children, and girls being molested, raped, violated. Some of them publicly. For example in a major landmark park, a tik tokker and nurse was violated by a group of hundreds of men. The security failed to protect her. The news rises like plastic waste on the oceans, leaving its disgusting debris on the shores of our screens. She was blamed, and not only that the public and media went after her as a person, and questioned her friendships and relationships.
The average Pakistani is still in love with their prime minister, Imran Khan. Never mind that None of the promises made by the PTI have been honoured. The much promised billions of dollars that Nawaz Sharif and family looted from Pakistan or the billions siphoned by Zardari are still floating in the air, between court cases. Pakistan’s debt is at an all time high. Apart from some administrative improvements, the government doesn’t seem to have lived up to its promise. When asked they blame previous governments for everything. The government released its universal curriculum in which it can be seen that Pakistaniyat or the identity of Pakistan has been once again associated with conservative patriarchy. In one text book cover, men and boys sit on sofas, girls and mothers occupy the floor. People throw around the opinion that Aurat March activists were funded by NGOs and that women talking about their objections to being used sexually in public is not indigenous. It seemed that here was some attempt being made to expose the sordid reality of Pakistan’s sexually violent culture, that lurks beneath the surface of religious propriety, making it nearly impossible to defend women and children against predators. However the Aurat march crowd has dissipated. Shamed, humiliated and persecuted on social media, many many women can’t take the trauma of being mistreated because they asked for Justice instead of accepting Just Is.
Noor Mukkadam’s murder is echoed by many other murders where men have murdered wives, children, friends and just random neighbourhood girls. The world is being shown that frustrated men take out their worst instincts on women. They scapegoat women and blame them for their own emotions. Many men from Pakistan blame Noor because she was part of the liberal Aurat March (women’s rights activist crowd) and one of the ‘liberal aunties’ who shouted the slogan, ‘My body, my rights’. For the average Pakistani mindset, this meant that a woman was asking for sex. The average man’s psyche struggles to see a woman as a human being. A Pakistani Muslim man believes that sex is bad, and the woman he has sex with is bad. Any woman he is attracted is responsible for his feelings, because if she were to remain invisible, he wouldn’t have sexual feelings about her. A woman just isn’t supposed to be free enough to use public space. And if she uses public space, she is likely to risk family criticism/blame, public humiliation, acid attacks, social media attacks, gossip and more recently torture and murder. In an ideal Muslim world, every corporation, every government, every road would have a separate space for women, so that they never see any men and no man sees them. In the Muslim mindset, the problem is that they are too liberal because of Western influence. A fundamentalist Muslim utopia is a place like Saudi Arabia, which masks extreme decadence behind a strict moral code. In this world view Muslim identity is bipolar, a snake pit of moral contradictions, where the purpose of existence is to kill all those who question what lies behind the mask.
People ask: Other countries have gang rape, murder etc., why does Pakistan’s sex crimes and violence against women create a fuss in liberal circles?
- Because sex crimes and violence against women is blamed on women existing. No other country says to a victim, you shouldn’t have worn these clothes, you shouldn’t have dated this man, you shouldn’t have gone out, you shouldn’t make vidoes, you shouldn’t be visible.
- Because every women’s right to public space, jobs, relationships and family is at stake every time someone is attacked because she was trying to exist as a human being.
- Because women are human and have equal value and worth as men; and they are not extensions of men in their lives.
- Because the worst kinds of mental health issues are covered up scapegoating women. Women are married off to men who are incapable of relationship, just because of family values, thus they often marry just for basic survival and shelter.
- Because a woman doesn’t feel as defensive about being a women anywhere else in the world as she does in Pakistan.